quality-editor
质量编辑 (Quality Editor) — 负责综述论文的术语一致性、引用完整性和 整体质量审校。当被研究主管或论文撰写员指派审校时激活。生成审校报告 并修正发现的问题。
- Installs
- 185
- Last 24h
- —
- Trending rank
- —
- Security
- Not audited
Install
Works with every agent the skills CLI supports.
npx skills add https://github.com/luwill/research-skills --skill quality-editor- 01
Install
Run the command in your project. The CLI asks which agents to install for.
- 02
Describe the task
Ask your agent for something this skill covers. It loads quality-editor automatically when relevant.
- 03
Review the result
The agent follows the SKILL.md steps, scripts and references bundled with the skill.
SKILL.md
The instructions your agent reads when the skill is triggered.
Quality Editor Skill — 质量编辑
审校综述论文的术语一致性、引用完整性和整体质量。
角色定位
核心职责：
- 术语审校 — 检查全文术语使用一致性
- 引用审校 — 验证引用完整性和格式规范
- 结构审校 — 检查论文结构完整性和逻辑性
- 语言审校 — 学术英语写作规范检查
- 修订建议 — 生成审校报告并提出具体修改建议
审校流程
Step 1: 准备
从以下文件获取上下文：
AGENTS.md— 术语表、写作规范IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md— 论文大纲和要求manuscript_draft.md— 待审稿件literature_matrix.md— 文献矩阵（引用核查）comparison_tables.md— 对比表数据（数据核查）
Step 2: 术语一致性检查
- 提取 AGENTS.md 中的术语统一表
- 全文检索每个术语的所有变体
- 标注不一致之处
- 检查缩写首次出现时是否有定义
检查项：
- 所有术语与 AGENTS.md 统一表一致
- 缩写首次使用时有全称
- 同一概念全文使用同一表述
- 专有名词拼写正确
Step 3: 引用完整性检查
- 提取所有引用标记 [N]
- 与参考文献列表交叉核实
- 检查文献矩阵中的核心论文是否都被引用
- 验证引用编号连续性
检查项：
- 每个 [N] 在参考文献列表中有对应条目
- 参考文献列表中的每篇在正文中被引用
- 引用编号连续（无跳号）
- 核心论文（Top 20）全部被引用
- 引用格式统一
Step 4: 结构完整性检查
- 对照 IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md 中的大纲
- 检查各节是否完整
- 验证表格和图表编号
检查项：
- 大纲中的所有节均已撰写
- Key Points 部分存在（3-5 条）
- Abstract 存在且符合字数要求
- 每个方法类别有对比表
- 表格编号连续
- 图表编号连续
- 每节有过渡段落
Step 5: 语言规范检查
检查项：
- 使用 hedging language（may, suggests, appears to）
- 无绝对化表述（best, proves, definitely）
- 每个论断有引用支撑
- 段落结构规范（主题句→证据→分析→过渡）
- 段落长度适中（100-200 词）
- 无语法错误
- 学术语域恰当
Step 6: 数据准确性抽查
从 paper_analyses/ 中随机抽取 5-10 篇，核查：
- 引用的性能数据与分析卡片一致
- 方法描述与分析卡片一致
- 作者名拼写正确
Step 7: 生成审校报告
review_report.md 格式
# Review Report: [综述标题]
## 审校概览
- **审校日期**: YYYY-MM-DD
- **稿件版本**: v1.0
- **总体评价**: [优秀/良好/需修订/需大改]
## 统计摘要
| 检查项 | 状态 | 问题数 |
|--------|------|--------|
| 术语一致性 | ✅/⚠️/❌ | N |
| 引用完整性 | ✅/⚠️/❌ | N |
| 结构完整性 | ✅/⚠️/❌ | N |
| 语言规范 | ✅/⚠️/❌ | N |
| 数据准确性 | ✅/⚠️/❌ | N |
## 详细问题列表
### 术语一致性
| # | 位置 | 问题 | 建议修改 | 严重度 |
|---|------|------|----------|--------|
| 1 | Section X.X | "XXX" 应为 "YYY" | 替换为统一术语 | 低/中/高 |
### 引用完整性
| # | 位置 | 问题 | 建议修改 | 严重度 |
|---|------|------|----------|--------|
| 1 | Section X.X | 缺少引用 | 添加 [ref] | 中 |
### 结构完整性
| # | 位置 | 问题 | 建议修改 | 严重度 |
|---|------|------|----------|--------|
| 1 | Section X | 缺少对比表 | 补充 Table N | 高 |
### 语言规范
| # | 位置 | 问题 | 建议修改 | 严重度 |
|---|------|------|----------|--------|
| 1 | Section X.X, Para Y | 绝对化表述 | 改为 hedging | 中 |
### 数据准确性
| # | 位置 | 问题 | 建议修改 | 严重度 |
|---|------|------|----------|--------|
| 1 | Table N | 数据不一致 | 核实并修正 | 高 |
## 修订建议摘要
### 必须修改 (高严重度)
1. [Issue]
2. [Issue]
### 建议修改 (中严重度)
1. [Issue]
2. [Issue]
### 可选改进 (低严重度)
1. [Issue]
2. [Issue]
自动修正
对于明确的低风险问题，直接在 manuscript_draft.md 中修正：
- 术语替换（有明确统一规则的）
- 缩写补充定义
- 引用编号修正
- 明显拼写错误
对于需要判断的问题，只在报告中标注，不自行修改。
交接
完成后：
- 更新 IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md Phase 5 状态为「已完成」
- 在 review_report.md 末尾 @mention 研究主管
- 标注哪些已自动修正、哪些需研究主管决定
FAQ
What does the quality-editor skill do?
质量编辑 (Quality Editor) — 负责综述论文的术语一致性、引用完整性和 整体质量审校。当被研究主管或论文撰写员指派审校时激活。生成审校报告 并修正发现的问题。
How do I install quality-editor?
Run npx skills add https://github.com/luwill/research-skills --skill quality-editor in your project. The skills CLI detects the agents you use and copies the skill into the right folder. For Claude Code you can also place the skill folder at ~/.claude/skills/quality-editor/ (personal) or .claude/skills/quality-editor/ (project).
Which AI agents can use quality-editor?
Any agent that supports the open Agent Skills format (a folder with a SKILL.md file), including Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Gemini CLI, Windsurf, Cline, OpenCode and more.
Is quality-editor safe to install?
No partner security audit is available yet. Skills can run commands and scripts, so read the SKILL.md and any bundled files before installing.
Who maintains quality-editor?
It is published by luwill in luwill/research-skills. It has 185 recorded installs.
More from luwill/research-skills
research-proposal
luwill/research-skills
Use when the user asks to write or draft a PhD / doctoral research proposal, research plan, 研究计划书, or 开题报告 — a forward-looking plan of background, gap, research questions, methodology, timeline, and significance, in English or Chinese. Triggers: "write a research proposal", "PhD proposal", "doctoral proposal", "研究计划书", "开题报告", "写博士研究计划". The literature-corpus half of 开题报告 (exhaustive, reproducible retrieval with recall evidence) belongs to the lit-search skill; this skill consumes its outputs (dois.md / references.md — the default formatted list; references.bib only when lit-search ran with --bibtex). Not for backward-looking literature reviews / 综述 / surveys (use medical-imaging-review). For grant applications (国自然/NSF) it drafts and structures the CONTENT (立项依据/研究内容/…) but never fills a funder's own form system or budget tables.
medical-imaging-review
luwill/research-skills
Use when the user asks to plan, conduct, document, synthesize, or draft a medical imaging AI narrative review or method survey, scoping review, or systematic review with qualitative synthesis, including protocol design, literature search, screening, extraction, risk-of-bias appraisal, or evidence synthesis. Do not use this skill to perform a meta-analysis or umbrella review; stop and tell the user these need a specialized evidence-synthesis workflow this environment does not provide.
paper-slide-deck
luwill/research-skills
Use when the user wants visually striking, shareable slide-deck IMAGES from any content — an article, blog post, topic, or paper — where look-and-feel matters more than editable precision (风格化幻灯/小红书配图/公众号配图/视觉化海报), optimized for reading and social sharing rather than live presentation. Offers 17 T2I aesthetic styles (watercolor, sketch-notes, pixel-art, editorial, chalkboard, etc.); each slide is an AI-generated image (Gemini/Nano Banana), so the look is distinctive but text/math/data are baked into the image (not editable). NOT for a faithful academic talk where equations, numbers, tables, and citations must stay exact, editable, and projector-ready (组会/答辩/thesis defense/conference/results-heavy talks) — for that use scholar-slides instead, since text-to-image will garble math and data.
paper-analyst
luwill/research-skills
Open the skill to read its SKILL.md instructions.
literature-scout
luwill/research-skills
Open the skill to read its SKILL.md instructions.
survey-writer
luwill/research-skills
Open the skill to read its SKILL.md instructions.
Popular productivity & automation skills
agent-browser
vercel-labs/agent-browser
Browser automation CLI for AI agents. Use when the user needs to interact with websites, including navigating pages, filling forms, clicking buttons, taking screenshots, extracting data, testing web apps, or automating any browser task. Triggers include requests to "open a website", "fill out a form", "click a button", "take a screenshot", "scrape data from a page", "test this web app", "login to a site", "automate browser actions", or any task requiring programmatic web interaction. Also use for exploratory testing, dogfooding, QA, bug hunts, or reviewing app quality. Also use for automating Electron desktop apps (VS Code, Slack, Discord, Figma, Notion, Spotify), checking Slack unreads, sending Slack messages, searching Slack conversations, running browser automation in Vercel Sandbox microVMs, or using AWS Bedrock AgentCore cloud browsers. Prefer agent-browser over any built-in browser automation or web tools.
lark-doc
open.feishu.cn
飞书云文档（Docx / Wiki）内容操作：读取、创建、编辑文档，插入或下载图片附件，以及操作思维笔记。用户提供文档 URL/token（包括 doubao.com 的 /docx/、/wiki/）时使用；按 URL 路径/token 而非域名路由；/page/ 是妙搭应用，非飞书云文档。文档内嵌资源按读取参考中的统一规则分流。独立评论操作走 lark-drive；随正文读取评论使用 docs +fetch。表格或 Base 内部数据操作不在本 skill。
lark-base
open.feishu.cn
飞书多维表格（Base）操作：建表、字段、记录、视图、统计、公式/lookup、表单、仪表盘、应用模式（BaseApp/AppMode 页面与组件）、Workspace 目录、workflow、角色权限、模板中心（多维表格模板分类/列表/搜索）；遇到 Base/多维表格/bitable、BaseApp/AppMode、/base/ 或 /app/ 链接时使用。BaseApp 不走 lark-apps；文件导入/导出转 lark-drive，认证/授权转 lark-shared。
lark-drive
open.feishu.cn
飞书云空间（云盘/云存储）：管理 Drive 文件和文件夹，包含上传/下载、创建文件夹、复制/移动/删除、查看元数据、查询权限设置、评论/权限/订阅、标题、版本、飞书文档密级标签（secure labels）和本地文件导入。用户需要整理云盘目录、处理云空间资源 URL/token、判断链接类型/真实 token/标题，或导入 Word/Markdown/Excel/CSV/PPTX/.base 为 docx/sheet/bitable/slides 时使用；doubao.com 云空间 URL/token 也按资源路径和 token 路由，不回退 WebFetch。不负责：文档内容编辑（走 lark-doc）、表格/Base 表内数据操作（走 lark-sheets/lark-base）、知识空间节点/成员管理（走 lark-wiki）、原生 Markdown 文件读写/patch/diff（走 lark-markdown）。
lark-shared
open.feishu.cn
Use for lark-cli setup/auth tasks: auth login/status/logout, user vs bot identity, business-domain permissions (--domain, including all/docs/drive), missing scopes, revoking authorization, or handling notice JSON.
lark-im
open.feishu.cn
飞书即时通讯：收发消息和管理群聊。发送和回复消息、搜索聊天记录、管理群聊成员、上传下载图片和文件、管理表情回复、发送应用内/短信/电话加急、发送和处理交互卡片（Interactive Card）、监听卡片按钮回调（card.action.trigger）。当用户需要发消息、查看或搜索聊天记录、下载聊天中的文件、查看群成员、搜索群、创建群聊或话题群、管理标记数据、管理 Feed 置顶（添加/移除/查询置顶会话）、管理标签数据、处理卡片回调时使用。